What's wrong with this story?

Its headline: Rep. Ellison calls the cops to snuff Tancredo’s cigar.

Its first four paragraphs:

Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.) believes it is his right as a Muslim to be sworn into Congress with the Quran. But apparently, the freshman lawmaker doesn’t believe it’s Rep. Tom Tancredo’s (R-Colo.) right to smoke a cigar in his congressional office.

Ellison’s office called the Capitol Hill Police on Tancredo last Wednesday night as Tancredo was in his office smoking a cigar. The lawmakers have neighboring offices on the first floor of the Longworth House Office Building.

Tancredo was still stunned a day later. “It’s very bizarre,” said Tancredo, who has never met Ellison. “Seemed to me not a good way to say hello.”

And let’s face it. Calling the cops on a colleague takes the cake for the nerviest behavior so far among members of this year’s freshman class of Congress.
Hmm. That does sound sorta nervy. Although, I note that even though the headline says that Rep. Ellison called the cops, by the second paragraph, it's just "his office" which called the Capitol Hill Police. Huh. Well, let's keep reading.

Its last two paragraphs:

Ellison’s press secretary, Rick Jauert, made the call to the Superintendent’s office when he noticed the smoke. “I called because the smoke was coming through the walls,” Jauert said, adding that the Superintendent’s office referred him to the Capitol Police.

Jauert said he then informed his boss what he had done. He said “fine,” Jauert said. “He’s complained of the smoke before.”
Wait—so a staffer for Rep. Ellison called the building super, because there was smoke coming through the walls, and then followed the super's direction to call the police? That doesn't really add up to "Rep. Ellison calls the cops to snuff Tancredo’s cigar" at all, now does it?

Bonus points to The Hill for not only being deliberately misleading, but also equating Tancredo's right to pollute adjacent offices with his bad habit (a bad habit which I shared until recently—and never felt I had "a right" to impose my smoke on anyone else) with Ellison's right to religious freedom.

Shakesville is run as a safe space. First-time commenters: Please read Shakesville's Commenting Policy and Feminism 101 Section before commenting. We also do lots of in-thread moderation, so we ask that everyone read the entirety of any thread before commenting, to ensure compliance with any in-thread moderation. Thank you.

blog comments powered by Disqus